The Unjust Justification for Revoking Asylum Seekers’ Visas

Christoper Landau: “You don’t get asylum because you fear persecution on account of a political opinion. You get asylum because you fear persecution on account of my political opinion.”

Leave a Comment

45 Comments

  1. Thanks for your help Jason. Quick question, what it means if you receive an uscis email alert that a decision has been made and mailed out on your already approved asylum since 2020?

    Reply
    • Apparently, this is happening to many people. It seems to be an error on USCIS’s part, and unless you hear something more from USCIS, I think you can safely ignore that message. Take care, Jason

      Reply
  2. Hello Jason,
    I recently received an update through my Senator regarding my pending RTD
    USCIS told the Senator’s office:
    “According to USCIS records, the case is currently in queue to be adjudicated.”

    Could you please explain what this status means in practical terms? Does it indicate that my case is actively awaiting review by an adjudicating officer, or is it simply a general status used for pending cases? ANY HOPE to get a decision soon? I’m so confused.

    I would also appreciate your opinion on whether this update is a positive development, whether it suggests that a decision may be approaching, and whether you recommend that I continue waiting or consider taking further legal action.

    I have attached the response from Senator Rand Paul’s office for your review.

    Thank you very much for your time and guidance.

    Sincerely,
    Mohamed Elnahas

    Reply
    • I don’t think the message has any particular meaning aside from the fact that the case is still pending. Presumably, unless there is a “hold” on a particular case, every RTD case is in the queue waiting to be adjudicated. To me, this is USCIS basically blowing off the Senator’s inquiry, and you might see if they (the Senator’s office) can do anything more, as the response from USCIS is really kind of insulting to the Senator and to you. Also, if you have a reason to try to expedite, maybe you can try that – I wrote about expediting in general on January 29, 2020. Otherwise, depending how long the case has been pending, you might consider a mandamus lawsuit to force USCIS to do its job. I would think that the case would have to be pending at least 1.5 years before a mandamus might work, but you can talk to a lawyer who does such cases in your area to see what they think. Take care, Jason

      Reply
  3. Hi Jason,

    If I am applying for a green card a year and a half after the asylum approval, do I need to submit evidence (rental leases, paystubs)that establishes that I have been residing in the US for a year? Or I don’t need to as it has been more than a year when I file? Thank you for all that you do for the community.

    Reply
    • I never submitted such evidence before, but I think it is a good idea to submit it now. I don’t know that you need much – maybe some tax documents or proof of employment or student status, or a lease/mortgage document. It also does not hurt these days to get a few letters stating that you are a person of good moral character. If you get such letters, the letter writers can also note that you have been physically present in the US for 1+ years. Take care, Jason

      Reply
  4. If someone applying for the N-400 on January 2nd 2027 then the 5-year tax transcript starts from the year 2022??? Or 2021?? Also if the interview takes place in 2028 so 2022 will be counted in as well or the 5-year count gonna start of 2023?

    Reply
    • Unfortunately, the Trump Administration eliminated the USCIS Ombudsman office and fired all its staff, so that is gone. Take care, Jason

      Reply
  5. Hey Jason,

    It’s been more than 16.5 months since I submitted my RTD application, and I’m still hearing nothing back. I even reached out to my senator for help and tried to expedite request, but nothing seems to work! What should I do next? I also came across a post on an immigration forum that mentioned RTDs are now taking 18-20 months for just a one-year VALIDITY travel document! What’s going on? Is USCIS trying to keep us stuck in the US?
    ………………………………………….
    (The latest quarterly report indicates 120768 in the backlog with the speed of 14806/quarter.
    This speed is about the same last (4) quarters.
    It converts to ~24.5 months of processing time if it goes in FIFO order.
    If you account for expedited requests, the number might go up slightly.

    For people who applied earlier, processing time might be lower.
    In example, I applied in July 2025(~94000 backlog at the time). Using the available data, I should get document in Feb/March of 2027 (19-20 months).

    Reply
    • Unfortunately, I think USCIS is trying to harm immigrants and asylees and the very long delays are one way to do that. USCIS will claim that it is related to “security,” but this seems to be complete nonsense. It seems to me that you are doing what you can do – contacting your representative and also trying to expedite. You might be able to do a mandamus case, as that is a way to force USCIS to do its job. You would have to talk to a lawyer who does such cases in your area to see if it might work, as it varies depending on the type of case and the location. Take care, Jason

      Reply
  6. I don’t know which candidate to support …

    The most pro-asylum one is AOC but she is not very electable.

    The electable ones are not very pro-asylum…

    What should I do…

    Reply
    • You are not the deciding factor lol, and why would you even consider the other side if they are against your interests? If someone is not electable but has your interests in mind vs. someone who apparently is electable but does not have your interests in mind, would you vote for the latter?

      Reply
      • There could be one that is not particularly pro-asylum but not extremely anti-asylum that I would prefer to see be elected…compared to the alternative…

        Reply
  7. Hi Jason,

    With the way things are going and evolving; especially after learning about applicants getting NTA from USCIS after filling applications and getting denials, I’m tempted to withdraw my naturalization application and just keep my green card for now. Things are getting too stressful and out of hands for me. What is your opinion?

    Reply
    • Unless you have some specific reason to worry about a denial, such as a criminal issue or an immigration problem (maybe your I-485 was inconsistent with your I-589, or there was evidence of prior fraud or misrepresentations), I do not think you need to withdraw. If you do want to withdraw, before you do that, maybe you want to consult with a lawyer to go over your case to look for any red flags and see if the lawyer thinks you are at risk. It would be better to naturalize, which will put you in a safer position given all the attacks on non-citizens, and so I would only withdraw if there is a real need to do that. Take care, Jason

      Reply
      • It looks like USCIS is looking for any reason to deny cases. I even recently heard of cases that were denied due to payment plans or late filing of taxes. In my specific case, my fear is that I come across a poorly trained officer (which could unfortunately a possibility) that is just looking for “red flags”. For instance, if you are a derivative and traveled with your passport of citizenship (not the country of feared persecution) she/he might now want to listen to your explanation and apply whatever discretion he/she has. This is a different agency. I will definitely hire a lawyer to assist but this whole atmosphere is overwhelming.

        Reply
        • Things are bad, but for the most part, they are not completely arbitrary. So for example, I think an asylee derivative would not be denied for traveling with the home country passport. I do think there are a lot of potential issues and USCIS is looking for reasons to deny, and I also think it can be helpful to have a lawyer. I just don’t think it is impossible to get approved for a GC, and so people should not give up hope. Take care, Jason

          Reply
  8. Hi Jason, I noticed USCIS now lists evidence of 1 year of physical presence after the asylum grant for asylees applying to get green cards.

    I filed my I-485 four months after my grant, so that wasn’t something I could include at the time.

    I’ve now met the one-year requirement. Is there a recommended way like a certain address to proactively submit this to instead of waiting for an RFE or denial. Thank you.

    Reply
    • You can mail additional evidence to the last USCIS address that sent you mail. Include a copy of the I-485 receipt so they can match your evidence with your case. Also, send it by certified mail and keep proof of delivery. You can also bring a copy of that evidence to the I-485 interview, since USCIS may lose what you send them. I suspect this will not be a problem since evidence of physical presence was not previously required in most cases, and so even if they send an RFE or require that you bring the evidence to the interview, you should be fine. I do think there is no harm in sending the evidence now; just make sure to keep a copy to bring to the interview as well. Take care, Jason

      Reply
  9. Hello Jason,
    https://www.uscis.gov/sites/default/files/document/guides/AAPM.pdf
    I was reviewing USCIS’s Affirmative Asylum Procedures Manual, updated in February 2025. On page 132, it states:
    “If there are two spouses who filed affirmative asylum applications separately as principal applicants (i.e., neither is a dependent on the other’s application) and both have completed their interviews and are waiting for decisions, during the adjudication process, if the asylum office determines that one applicant is eligible for approval and the other is not eligible, the asylum office personnel inform the prospective dependent that they are ineligible for asylum approval as a principal applicant. If the prospective dependent who is ineligible as a principal applicant would like to be added to the eligible principal applicant’s application, the eligible principal applicant must provide the request to include the new dependent in writing.”
    From an immigration attorney’s perspective, do you know whether USCIS/Asylum Offices actually follow this procedure in practice when adjudicating and issuing decisions in cases involving spouses who filed separate affirmative asylum applications?
    Thank you very much for helping us.

    Reply
    • When I have done cases like this, the spouses were listed as dependents on each other’s asylum application, so this was not an issue. Otherwise, I do not know whether they follow this procedure in the case of spouses who are not listed as dependents on the other person’s application. If one spouse is granted and one is denied/referred to court, you can ask the asylum office to reopen the denied spouse’s case based on this language, and that may work. We do sometimes have luck with reopening cases at the asylum office after they have been sent to court. Take care, Jason

      Reply
  10. Hi Jason.

    Thank you for sharing the news and keeping the asylum community informed. Over the 4 years since I applied, this website has become a place I keep coming back to for news, although unfortunately, it is usually anxiety-inducing.

    I wanted to reach out to see if you could provide a data point, understanding the overall uncertainty of the process. I had an interview with a Chicago asylum office at their Kansas City field office roughly 4 weeks ago. The interview was scheduled 4 years after the application. Affirmative asylum, fear of political prosecution in one of the former Soviet Union bloc countries. I was looking online for information on processing times and found that KC is notoriously slow, but all the data points I could find were related to naturalization, marriage-based GC, OPT, and other non-asylum applications.
    My attorney said that it’s very hard to forecast wait times, and it compounds for multiple reasons: valid immigration status, 500+ pages of evidence, field office rather than main office, etc. In your practice, what is the reasonable amount of time to wait for a decision after the interview? It’s been almost a month of daily status checks, and I’m not sure what would be considered a reasonable time after which a follow-up would be warranted. How are the offices treating requests to expedite the decision? Does it annoy them, and is it best to lay low and hope for a resolution soon, or is it worth asking the attorney to send them an email to remind them about yourself after some time?

    Thank you

    Reply
    • I agree with your lawyer that it is not predictable, unfortunately. That is true for all cases, but especially true for asylum cases. Some people get decisions within days of the interview; others wait years. Most people have a decision in a few months, but it really varies. I think it is too soon to inquire about your case, but maybe if there is nothing after another month or two, you can inquire. I wrote about the process of inquiring on March 30, 2022. Take care, Jason

      Reply
  11. Hi, I have a pending BIA appeal after my asylum case was denied and I was issued a removal order. I was advised not to withdraw my appeal while I’m still in the U.S. because the judge’s removal order would become final, and that it may be better to withdraw it after I leave the country. I’m planning to leave permanently and I’m no longer concerned about continuing the appeal. I just want to make sure I can leave safely and without being detained at the airport. Is this the best approach, and is there anything I should do before leaving?

    Reply
    • I have not had a client leave under those circumstances, and so I am not sure. I do think it would be worth using looking at the CBP One app, to see if that will work in your situation. If so, it could help reduce any risk that you will be detained. Otherwise, it makes sense to not withdraw the appeal until after you leave, as you are currently a pending asylum seeker. If you withdraw the appeal, you will have a removal order. One other option may be to ask the BIA for “voluntary departure.” This allows you to leave the US without a deportation order, which potentially makes it easier to come back one day. I do not know whether you are eligible for voluntary departure, but it may be worth discussing with a lawyer. Take care, Jason

      Reply
  12. Asylum
    1. If you filed for asylum 10yrs ago and in court 4yrs now, do uscis plan to send you letter for entry visa cancellation while you are in court or when your no longer have the entry Visa? Visa was expired 9yrs and 6months ago?

    Uvisa
    2. If you have a Uvisa case ongoing where you obtain 3 BFD with an EAD for 4yrs, your family took fingerprinting 1.5yrs for a Uvisa, do this new Trump visa cancelation apply to you when you also have an asylum case in court 6yrs and no hearing no final asylum decision. Will uscis go after you for your entry visa cancelation which got expired years back?
    Will uscis cancel your Uvisa pending which may have 2 or 3yrs remaining to be issued to you and your family?
    when you are issue a final Uvisa, does the uvisa cancel any other visa you had lke B1/B2, student or other non-immigrant visa? Or only the Uvisa GC cancel the other visas which come after another 3yrs?
    Will USCIS allow your family to come to the US immediately if your uvisa is approved since they have done their fingerprinting and waiting visa also?

    Thanks.

    Reply
    • 1 – I do not know, but if they did, it would have no effect since the visa has already expired. 2 -I don’t see how the visa cancellation would affect a U visa. Maybe the fact that the State Department is effectively accusing you of lying to get a visa could be a negative factor in your case, but that factor exists whether they cancel the visa or not. In other words, they do not need to cancel the visa to accuse you of having lied to get the visa. I also do not see how cancelling the old visa would affect your family. Whether they will be able to come to the US depends on whether/when the U visa is issued. The government is trying all sorts of ways to block people from getting visas (such as the current “pause” on all immigration visas), and so your family’s ability to come to the US will depend on whether the government is issuing visas at all (and on whether the U visa is approved for each person). I do not see how the effort to cancel old visas for asylum seekers will affect any of this. Take care, Jason

      Reply
  13. Hi Jason, quick question regarding a friend’s case: His asylum claim was referred to immigration court, but his brother’s petition for him is now ready to move forward. Since he’s currently in the U.S., can he adjust status from here, or does he have to return home to proceed? Thanks for your advice.

    Reply
    • It is very unlikely that he could get his GC based on his brother’s petition without leaving the US. There is a called INA 245(i) that might allow it, but he would have had to have been inside the US prior to December 20, 2000, among other requirements. If that is the case, he can talk to a lawyer to see whether that law is an option, and if so, the lawyer can (and should) explain the details of how it might work. If 245(i) is not an option, it is still worth discussing the specifics with a lawyer to see whether maybe there is anything else. I very much doubt it, but it is worth a conversation to be sure. If not, he may be able to take “voluntary departure” and process his GC overseas. He needs to be sure that he has no legal bar to returning to the US, so he would need to discuss that with a lawyer as well. I am guessing that none of these options is likely to work, and so probably he will have to present his asylum case to the judge. If so, he may want to request voluntary departure as an alternative to asylum; that way, if he loses the case, he can try to preserve the option of processing the GC overseas (voluntary departure does not prevent him from appealing an asylum denial to the BIA). Again, this is something to discuss with a lawyer as he prepares his case. Take care, Jason

      Reply
  14. Dear Jason,

    I’d like to ask you about my situation if I may. I got GC based on marriage. Several months ago I applied to expedited citizenship status since I was still in the happy marriage. Recently I got the interview all went well. However a few days ago me and my spouse got into this huge argument over our budget and it went awfully bad. We no longer see us as a couple. I assumed I’d be called soon to say the auth and complete the naturalization. Am I still eligible for that?

    Reply
    • The requirement is that you are legally married, and not that you have a good marriage. I suppose if you/your spouse start divorce proceedings, it may be an issue and you might want to talk with a lawyer. But at this stage, it sounds like you had a big fight and the future of the relationship is not clear. As far as I know, you will not be asked again about the marriage when you go to the naturalization appointment, but if you are, you will have to answer honestly. At this point, though, it seems to me that you are still married, even if your/your spouse’s intention is to end the marriage. I would keep documentation about all these events, as it will look suspicious if you get divorced shortly after you become a citizen, and you would want to have evidence about how the marriage ended (if it ends), just in case you are ever questioned about this. Take care, Jason

      Reply
  15. Hi Jason,

    I received a RFE for my EAD renewal. They will send an appointment to go to one of USCIS places so they can take my picture ? Is this something normal ? What is the likelihood of encountering ICE there ? I have a pending asylum case, originally from Afghanistan.

    Reply
    • I have not heard about that before, and so I am not sure. Is this just a biometric appointment? If so, that would be normal. You may want to have a lawyer look at your notice to see if it seems suspicious, as they do sometimes try to trick people into coming to their office so they can be detained. You (and everyone else with a pending case) should also have a plan in place in case you are detained. Take care, Jason

      Reply
      • Thank you Jason,

        The notice looks legit, and a copy of notice was downloaded from USCIS account, and copy was sent it the law firm too.

        Also, what is your email address Jason ? Please

        Reply
          • Hi Jason,

            I have/had a case with you. But then after you came to Murray, it was transferred to one of their lawyers. (But I didn’t authorize them yet).

            So you are no longer with Murray ? Can I still have my case managed by you ?

          • I have left the private practice of law and the cases were transferred to Murray Osorio, so they would be able to assist with the case. I am not able to assist further with private cases and all my client files are now with the new firm. It sounds like they (and maybe I) were in touch with you about this, but you should follow up with them if you have questions. Take care, Jason

          • I see. That’s a loss for asylum seekers who need representations. But I am glad you are still able to contribute in other ways to the community.

            What do you think of the new generation of immigration/asylum lawyers ? Are they competent ?

            This generation is becoming more and more anti-immigration and anti-asylum. So I would expect less amount of talents and less quality of talents getting in the pool while tenured advocates exit the scene…

            This is very worrying to me

          • The younger lawyers I met were really very good. They are often over-worked, but that is pretty normal for a new lawyer. They also know the law and are able to navigate all the on-line platforms far better than I can. Take care, Jason

  16. Hi Jason,
    I got my asylum approval in Aug 2024 and applied for GC in Feb 2025, but i haven’t received my GC yet. Now with them revoking the b1/b2 visas, should i be worried about domestic travel? I travel a lot for work.
    Backstory, i entered USA by b1/b2 visa in 2017 and applied for asylum after the 6 months admission.

    Reply
    • I am not sure that the visa revocation will apply to people who already have asylum, but we shall see. Even if the visa is revoked, it would have no effect on you, since you already have a different status in the US (asylum). I have not heard about anyone with asylum having trouble traveling domestically, and so I do not see that you would have a problem. Also, for the green card case, USCIS has been getting slower and slower, and that is particularly true for GC applications filed by asylees. So while you have been waiting for a while, that is normal (unfortunately). Take care, Jason

      Reply
      • You are no longer required to wait the full year – I wrote about that on February 8, 2023. As far as I know, that rule is still in effect, but things are changing very rapidly with USCIS, so if you plan to file prior to one year after winning asylum, you should double check the I-485 instructions or speak with a lawyer. Take care, Jason

        Reply