A recent article in the Yale Law Journal by Jason A. Cade analyzes BIA decisions from the second Trump Administration. The article’s title is self-explanatory: “Welcome to the Trump Administration’s Board of Immigration Appeals. The Immigrant Always Loses.“
At one time, the BIA aspired to be the “Supreme Court of Immigration,” but under Trump 2.0, it exists only to deny relief to non-citizens and truncate due process of law. Professor Cade argues that the Board’s anti-immigrant “project” deserves little deference from the federal courts, and calls on those courts to protect immigrants and defend due process.
Historically, the BIA issued few published decisions and generally provided insufficient guidance to Immigration Judges and USCIS (hence my brilliantly titled–if I do say so myself–article, The Unbearable Lightness of BIA-ing). But since Mr. Trump returned to office in January 2025, the Board has been issuing precedential decisions at a breakneck pace–roughly three times its prior average. According to Prof. Cade’s review, more than 98% of these cases were resolved “in the same direction” (i.e., against the immigrant).
The main reason for the uniform direction of these decisions is that BIA “membership was purged and rebuilt for ideological alignment” with Mr. Trump’s agenda. Of the 28 BIA judges on the Board in January 2025, at least thirteen were fired, including every judge appointed during President Biden’s term. The current BIA judges are committed to a very restrictive view of the immigration law and of non-citizens’ due process rights.

Asylum seekers have been particularly hard hit by the BIA’s new direction. Thirty-six of the first 100 precedential decisions of President Trump’s second term address asylum, Withholding of Removal, and claims under the Convention Against Torture (CAT). “Although these are formally distinct forms of protection with different requirements,” Prof. Cade writes, the Board “narrows all three.”
Within months of assuming office, Attorney General Pam Bondi “gutted asylum claims based on domestic violence and gang persecution,” and established “that private conduct will almost never qualify an applicant for protection in the United States, even where the country-of-origin government is unwilling or unable to control that conduct.” The AG also limited asylum protections for people targeted due to family membership, and reinstated a rule that “eliminated the ‘duress exception’ to the persecutor bar.”
The BIA followed the AG’s lead and issued decisions designed to foreclose “gender-based asylum claims at the threshold, before any individualized merits review.” The Board also sought to limit claims based on political opinion, holding that the political opinion must relate “to a government,” including a “de facto government.” In other words, opposition to a non-state actor is no longer considered a “political opinion” for purposes of asylum.
The Board has also endorsed dismissal of asylum, Withholding, and CAT claims based on “recently expanded asylum cooperative agreements… which authorize the removal of asylum seekers to countries with which they have no connection for consideration of their claims there.” Under BIA precedent, asylum seekers have little opportunity to argue that they would not be safe in the third country, or that they would not get a fair asylum hearing in that country.

The BIA has also raised the standard for CAT relief. Unless government officials “specifically created the harsh [prison] conditions in order to inflict severe pain and suffering rather than to deter crime,” an applicant cannot qualify for CAT protection. Absent the specific intent to inflict torture, even “documented widespread suffering in state custody is considered ordinary penal administration, not warranting protection” under the Torture Convention.
Recent Board decisions have elevated the State Department Country Reports and downgraded human rights reports from NGOs, such as Human Rights Watch and Amnesty International. Given that the State Department reports have largely white washed human rights abuses (especially related to women and sexual minorities), this will make it more difficult for asylum seekers to prove a likelihood of harm.
Other BIA decisions convert “the circumstances of a non-citizen’s survival into evidence against their claim of enduring risk.” In other words, if the asylum applicant avoids the persecutor by not dying, it demonstrates the possibility of living safely in the home country by relocating or getting protection from the authorities, or that the threats faced by the applicant were not so serious after all.
I’ll highlight one last point (though Prof. Cade makes many more), which is that the BIA has surreptitiously changed the standard of review. Previously, factual determinations by an Immigration Judge were entitled to great deference. But now, under the guise of reviewing legal findings, the BIA has engaged in “a pattern of evidentiary manipulation and impermissible factfinding” which allows it to reach its “predetermined outcome: removal.” Put another way, the Board pretends that judges’ factual findings were actually legal findings, which makes it easier for them to overturn decisions favorable to the non-citizen.

Aside from asylum, the Board has restricted protection for non-citizens in a myriad of other ways. The Board has dramatically expanded mandatory detention for many people and made it more difficult for others to qualify for release on bond. It has narrowed “discretionary relief for non-citizens with criminal histories,” and has more broadly defined “conduct that triggers fraud-based removability” and reduced opportunities for waivers (forgiveness). The BIA has tightened the hardship requirements for Cancellation of Removal, and blocked non-citizens from requesting additional time or reopening a closed case so that USCIS can adjudicate a benefit (such as a Special Immigrant Juvenile Green Card or a U visa for crime victims), and it has expanded the use of in absentia removal orders. On top of all this, fees for an appeal increased from $110 to $1060, making it financially prohibitive for some applicants to obtain BIA review.
According to Prof. Cade, these efforts “constitute a coordinated conversion of an adjudicative system nominally committed to individualized review into one engineered to produce a predetermined result.”
What can be done? Prof. Cade looks to the federal courts for help. He points out that a 2024 Supreme Court decision, Loper Bright Enterprises v. Raimondo, offers some hope. Prior to Loper Bright, “federal courts reviewing BIA legal interpretations… accept[ed] the agency’s reasonable construction of ambiguous statutory provisions even when the reviewing court might have read the statute differently.” But after Loper Bright, “courts review questions of statutory interpretation de novo, owing the agency’s view no special deference.” This means that federal courts can more easily overturn BIA decisions.
Prof. Cade’s article has done an important service. By aggregating the BIA’s decisions since January 2025, he has helped quantify and reveal the Board’s “project” to dramatically restrict relief for non-citizens. He has pointed out, in effect, that the emperor has no clothes. But to paraphrase Neil Gaiman, It has always been the prerogative of children and fools (and academics) to point out that the emperor has no clothes. However, in the end, the emperor is still an emperor and the fool is still a fool. Here, though, perhaps this view is too cynical. Prof. Cade has also mapped out a path for the federal courts to reverse some of the damage. Let us hope they take heed.
Hi, I filed my I-485 in April 2023 and completed my interview on August 26, 2026. My case is still pending, and I have not received any decision or update since the interview. Is this amount of delay normal, and is there anything I should do at this point?
Some people get decisions quickly after the interview; others wait many months, and so the delay you are describing is not at all unusual. At this stage, you can contact the asylum office to inquire about your decision. I wrote an article dated March 30, 2022 that discusses how to do that and gives an example email you can send. Take care, Jason
Never Temu Vs Holder
Do you mind if I ask why you left private practice ? And how are you able to make sure that the clients you would have been able to help have you not left will get corresponding quality of representation ? I am just worried that since the legal resources are badly needed at this point, any reduction of available legal resources is detrimental to the asylum community.
I have been working as a lawyer for 30 years, and it was time for a change. The lawyers at the firm where I moved my cases are very good, and I feel like they are more able to keep up with all the changes in the law, and they have more resources than I ever did, and so I think the clients are probably receiving better assistance than I could have given them. Take care, Jason
I wish you the best in your next adventure and life. I ll forever be grateful to you for how you handled my asylum case. Every time I remember the moment I opened this letter from asylum office, my heart feel extremely warm ,I think of you.Big up of all the staff ,trainee who I met in your office Gisela,Emilia,it really was good memories.
I wish you all the best.
Thank you for the kind words. We still get letters like that once in a while. Here’s hoping for more. Take care, Jason
Hi Jason,
I am a derivative asylee and I applied for naturalization. I am wondering how is the impact of a 7 days trip to my home country will affect the process? I am a derivative from a different country from the principal and never filed a claim against my country. Will/can the government use that against me and claim re-a ailment? It’s really unclear to me. Should I hire an attorney to go to the interview?
If I understand correctly, you were the dependent on an asylum case and the principal (who got asylum) is from a different country as you? If so, I do not think you face a risk by returning to your country, which is not the country where the principal applicant was persecuted. It is possible that you will be asked about your travel, as some immigration officers are not very good at their jobs, and they may not understand the difference between a dependent asylee and a principal asylee (sadly, I am not joking about this). For that reason, it would be good to be able to explain that you are a dependent from a different country, and to have access to evidence about the old asylum case (such as the principal’s I-589 showing that the person is from a different country as you). I doubt you will need this, but maybe you can have a copy of the form saved somewhere so you can access it on your computer or phone, in case you are asked. Otherwise, I do not see that you should have any problem traveling. Take care, Jason
Hi Jason,
I just want your opinion on the likelihood of DHS appealing a grant in a case where they did not file any evidence, missed responsive documents deadline and at the trial, no cross examination for both respondent and witness and barely raised any argument nor object to evidence provided. DHS reserved appeal
Hi Jason,
What is the likelihood of DHS appealing a case where they did not provide any evidence, missed both cross service and responsive documents deadlines and at the trial, they did not cross examine the applicant and the witness and barely raise any argument. IJ granted the case and DHS reserved appeal. Will appreciate your opinion.
Hi Jason,
What is the likelihood of DHS appealing a case where they never submitted any evidence,missed deadline for cross service and responsive documents and at the trial, never cross examined the respondent and her witness. Yet they reserve appeal
DHS almost always reserves appeal these days. They do not always appeal, and in the case you are describing, it sounds like they were not making much effort and so it is probably not a priority for them. In a case like this, I doubt they would appeal. Of course, you never know, and you really have to wait until about 35 days after the court decision to be sure an appeal was not filed, as DHS often files at the last minute and then, for some reason, we don’t always learn about it until a few days after the 30-day appeal deadline. Take care, Jason
Hi Jason,
For those who are due for the annual asylum fee, how should they proceed to the payment if they haven’t received a notice? Last year the notice was sent in Oct and I had paid a couple days before the notice was sent. USCIS also sent the receipt notice a couple days later as well. But I’ve been trying the payment portal with USCIS every days for 2 months and it always says the payment for this case is not due at this time. And I haven’t received any notice yet this year either. So, it’s been a week past the time I paid last year but the payment somehow is not still not available. Should I keep waiting until the annual fee notice sent or is there anything I should do instead? Thank you!
Best,
The system is a mess. You should get a notice, but there seems to be confusion from the government about the second annual fee payment. Some people have received notices, and so hopefully you will get one soon. I think you can keep trying to pay, but if it does not work, take a screen shot and keep that as evidence of your efforts to pay. Make sure to also note the date and time. I do not think cases will be dismissed for failure to pay, but this is obvious yet another unnecessary burden the government is placing on asylum seekers in order to harm them. Take care, Jason
Hi Jason,
TPS for Ukrainians was set to expire on October 19, 2026. No new time frames or guidelines have been posted by USCIS except for one alert that reads: “An announcement on Ukraine’s TPS will be made at the appropriate time. Until such announcement is made, Ukrainian individuals present in the U.S. under TPS retain protection including work authorization.”
Can a person who never had approved TPS and the initial application for TPS is still pending (since February 2025), but they had a work authorization card valid until October 19, 2026 under this application approved – can they keep working based on this announcement or it only concerns to those with approved TPS?
Thank you for all your time and help in our community!
USCIS did the same thing for El Salvador TPS, and there is really no clean guidance on this. As a result, TPS people have sometimes lost their jobs or been preventing from getting a driver’s license. The rules on TPS require the government to announce TPS at least 6 months before they end it, and so most lawyers (including me) believe that people from El Salvador, and now Ukraine and Sudan, who had TPS can continue working lawfully. The USCIS website seems to indicate this, but some employers are being extra cautious and firing people who do not have current work permits. In your case, I do not quite understand the situation, as you say that your TPS was never approved, but you got a work permit based on TPS? Given that it seems TPS has been extended, I would guess that your work permit is also extended, but you may want to talk to a lawyer to look into this (though honestly, there is not a lot of guidance and I do not know that a lawyer researching this question will find an answer). If you have an employer and they are not sure what to do, the best thing may be to look at the USCIS website, which should indicate that TPS people are allowed to continue working. Take care, Jason
Thank you for your reply, Jason! This is my mom’s situation: in February 2025 she applied for TPS for the first time ever and along with that application she submitted an application for work authorization connected to that TPS request. The application for work authorization was approved immediately (within days, and within like a week she received the actual card). But the application for TPS remains pending. We actually even submitted an expedite request yesterday due to financial loss because last week her job said that she cannot continue working without a valid EAD card. And within hours of our submission yesterday her job called her again to let her know that she can return – because they ran some checks that confirmed she is allowed to work; they also stated that USCIS sent them some guidance and her expired EAD category was on their list for approved extension.
She has not returned yet as we are trying to be cautious and research everything to confirm.
I will be applying for citizenship in a little over a year and hopefully later will be able to apply for a green card for her. So, we are trying to avoid any problems in the future / not engage in any unlawful employment.
All of this is very confusing. To me, the language reads that TPS protections are extended only to people who had TPS. But she only had an EAD card under TPS. We will try calling USCIS for some clarity this week. And she will probably return to work since her employer insists all is cleared and lawful.
If you look on her EAD card, there should be a code: A-12 is approved for TPS and C-19 is TPS pending (I think that is correct – I am not 100% sure I remember these correctly). If the EAD indicates her TPS is approved, she should be able to rely on that, even if she did not receive a notice about the TPS application itself. If the card indicates TPS is pending, it may be a different story, but I am not sure how those are being treated by USCIS. Again, there may be no answer to this question, as USCIS has not provided guidance, but she may want to have a lawyer look into it in more detail, or maybe she can ask the employer to send her the info they have, which might help confirm her eligibility to work. Finally, in normal times (i.e., before Trump part 2), working without authorization would not have blocked her from getting a GC based on an adult US citizen child. However, now, that can be a reason to deny a GC, and so I think you are right to be careful. Take care, Jason
Thank you, Jason! Her card states Category C19. And her employer said that the guidance that they received from USCIS allows C19 people to continue working. I hear people online also mentioning E-Verify. We’ve never used it. Can this be a reliable way to confirm her eligibility?
You can only do so much, given that USCIS has largely failed to provide any info, but maybe you can get a copy of the guidance that the employer is using. If it seems clear, then that is probably sufficient. If it is not clear, maybe you can have a lawyer look at it, or if the employer already had a lawyer look at it, maybe they would share the lawyer’s opinion with you. I have not used e-verify either. It is for employers, but if your employer used that and got a result, you could ask them to share that as well. Take care, Jason
Hi Jason,
I hope you are doing well. I need your insight for my case.
I would like to mandamus for my green card application but I am not sure my delay time is a strong case for mandamus and what’s happening right now post mandamus cases.
Submitted asylum application February 2018
Granted asylum December 2023
Became eligible for permanent residency December 2024
Submitted I-485 permanent residency application in February 2025.
If mandamus is accepted, are they interviewing everyone? Is approval chance in interview very low? My concern is I applied for asylum after more than 1 year I came to US. They accepted “changed circumstances” during my asylum decision but I am wondering if they will reconsider this and just cancel everything??
I highly doubt USCIS would reconsider your asylum grant, and so I don’t think that is a real worry. However, I also think it is probably too soon to file a mandamus. You can check processing times at http://www.uscis.gov, but I expect your case is still within the “normal” processing times for asylee I-485 cases. That doesn’t necessarily mean you can’t file a mandamus, but you would want to talk with a lawyer in your area who does such cases to see if you have waited long enough. Maybe after two years, it would be more likely to work, but talk to a lawyer to see what they think. Take care, Jason
Hello Jason,
Just a quick question, i was told all approved cases are getting interviewed by uscis for green card, so thats not really the case? Can you please clarify?
I am not sure I understand your question, but if you are asking whether people who were granted asylum are being interviewed when they apply for a Green Card, the answer is yes. Supposedly all asylees who apply for a GC are being interviewed, and in some cases, the interview includes questions about the prior asylum case, so you need to review the asylum case and the I-485 application prior to the interview, so you are ready for any questions. Take care, Jason
Hello Jason,
Not the person who asked question but arent all approved cases by asylum office getting interviewed for adjustment of status for green card? I was told by a lawyer that thats the case nowadays. Appreciate your response, thank you
I don’t remember the exact announcement, but I have also heard that all GC applicants are being interviewed. I do know of at least one recent case (from a couple months ago) where the GC applicant was not interviewed and just received her card in the mail after she applied. However, I think almost everyone is being interviewed. Take care, Jason
That’s interesting. Was it due to the asylees country of birth?
I have no idea. I forget which country the person was from, sorry. Take care, Jason